Start with each author’s main point. When a question gives you two passages, the worst thing you can do is blend them together in your memory. Before comparing anything, pin down each passage’s main idea separately: what is Passage 1 claiming, and what is Passage 2 claiming? Only once you hold both clearly can you see how they relate. It often helps to sum up each in a short phrase — "Passage 1: online learning saves money; Passage 2: online learning hurts focus" — so the two stay distinct.
Agreement and disagreement. Two passages on the same topic can relate in several ways. They may agree on the conclusion but offer different reasons. They may disagree, taking opposite positions. They may address the same topic from different angles — one focused on cost, the other on quality — without directly contradicting each other. Or they may share facts but draw different conclusions from them. Your task is usually to identify exactly where they line up and where they part ways.
Watch for the swap. The most common wrong answer in a compare-contrast question attaches one passage’s view to the other author. A choice will say "Passage 2 argues X" when in fact Passage 1 argued X and Passage 2 argued the opposite. This is why keeping the two main points clearly labeled matters so much — the test is counting on readers to lose track of who said what. Before selecting an answer, double-check that each half of it is pinned to the correct passage.
Comparing tone and purpose. Beyond their claims, two passages may differ in tone or purpose. One might be a calm, neutral explanation while the other is a heated argument. One might aim to inform, the other to persuade. Questions sometimes ask you to notice these differences in how the passages are written, not just what they say. The same fact can be presented admiringly in one text and critically in another.
The method: state each passage’s main point in your own words and keep them labeled. Identify whether the passages agree, disagree, or approach the topic differently. When choosing an answer, verify that each claim in it is matched to the correct author.
Worked example:
Passage 1: City gardens are worth every dollar. They give neighbors a place to meet, turn empty lots into green space, and put fresh vegetables within reach of families who need them.
Passage 2: City gardens sound charming, but the land they occupy could house far more people. In a city short on housing, using scarce lots for tomatoes is a luxury we cannot afford.
Passage 1’s point: city gardens provide real community and food benefits. Passage 2’s point: that land would be better used for housing. They share a topic — city gardens on urban lots — but reach opposite conclusions. A wrong answer might claim both value the gardens, when only Passage 1 does.
Comparing and Contrasting Texts Review Quiz
Time limit: 0
Quiz Summary
0 of 4 Questions completed
Questions:
Information
You have already completed the quiz before. Hence you can not start it again.
